The TLX is a design-first sedan with polarizing trade-offs. Its aggressive exterior wins universal praise, but the cramped cabin, smaller than a Civic inside despite 5-series footprint, is a deal-breaker for many. The 2015-2020 V6 models suffer systematic rod bearing failures requiring engine replacement, though the current-gen (2021+) uses a different powertrain. The Type S looks compelling at $53k base but disappoints enthusiasts: it's a full second slower to 60 than the M340i while costing nearly as much after options and dealer markups. Community consensus: buy it for the looks and SH-AWD if you don't need rear seat space, but the Accord 2.0T or German rivals offer better value for most buyers. Production ends 2025.
The WRX splits opinion between those who want a practical AWD sedan with some punch and those chasing the rally-bred legend. The vertical touchscreen is a genuine annoyance, owners hate it, and if you're considering the CVT automatic, you're looking at the wrong car entirely. The manual is the only version that makes sense, but be realistic about stop-and-go commutes. As a first car for a 16-year-old? Terrible idea: the insurance alone will hurt, and 280+ horsepower is more than most new drivers can handle responsibly. For experienced drivers who need year-round capability and weekend fun, it's a solid choice, but the current generation has lost some of the raw character that made earlier versions cult favorites.