This three-row crossover splits into two completely different vehicles by generation. The 2011-2019 Theta II models are mechanical time bombs, engines grenade between 50k-90k miles with oil burning and rod knock, leaving families stranded for months while dealers work through warranty backlogs. The 2024 redesign threw out that cursed powertrain entirely, but introduced two new problems: panoramic sunroofs that explode while driving (glass raining into the cabin, corporate denying coverage), and a 2024 dual-clutch transmission already failing at low mileage. The 2026 hybrid with conventional automatic looks promising, owners report 470-mile range and Range Rover looks at $50k, but it's too new to trust long-term. If you're buying used, the Theta II era is a hard pass. If you're buying new, the hybrid might be worth the gamble, but skip the sunroof and prepare to fight corporate if anything breaks. Honda Passport and Mazda CX-90 offer less drama.
The Toyota Highlander shows a sharp generational divide: pre-2020 models earn strong loyalty with owners reporting 200k-300k mile longevity, while 2020-2023 models face systematic 8-speed transmission complaints and class action lawsuits. The 2024-2026 hybrids have a fire recall related to inverter assembly. Many buyers question the Toyota premium, noting Kia and Hyundai offer better value with more features. The announced 2027 EV-only transition with limited range concerns families who use Highlanders for long trips. Current owners praise comfort and practicality, but value perception is a major pain point.