← Back to Verdikt

Maytag MED5630 Electric Dryer vs Whirlpool WGD6605 Gas Dryer

Honest head-to-head from real owner consensus
Whirlpool WGD6605 Gas Dryer comes out ahead overall (7.3 vs 4.6), but the breakdown below shows where each one wins.
Dimension by dimension
 Maytag MED5630 Electric DryerWhirlpool WGD6605 Gas Dryer
Reliability & Durability 5.0 6.7
User Sentiment 4.4 8.1
Complaint Severity 6.8 6.4
Consensus Strength 2.7 3.6
Value for Money 2.6 5.6
Owner Advocacy 2.0 8.0
Maytag MED5630 Electric Dryer

A no-frills electric dryer that dries clothes and nothing else, built on the same mechanical platform Whirlpool has used for decades. The heating element will burn out eventually (typically after several years of regular use), but replacement runs under $50 and takes an hour if you're handy. Skip this one: little enthusiasm, Maytag's quality reputation has slipped from its glory days, and competitors at the same price point offer better long-term reliability without asking you to become an appliance technician.

Whirlpool WGD6605 Gas Dryer

This is the dryer equivalent of a cast-iron skillet: proven 1970s engineering that Whirlpool still builds because it works and people can fix it themselves when it doesn't. The control board can fail and leave the drum spinning until you physically open the door, and gas valve coils sometimes quit mid-cycle, letting raw gas smell seep out until you swap the part, both fixes are cheap and YouTube-able, but neither should happen on a machine this simple. Buy it if you value a 15-year lifespan and $20 repair bills over moisture sensors and app notifications; skip it if a dryer that occasionally needs a screwdriver sounds like more involvement than you signed up for.