Mazda built a compact crossover that drives like a sport sedan and lasts like a Toyota, then fumbled the 2026 redesign by burying climate controls in a touchscreen. The 2017-2025 generation is the sweet spot: upscale interior, engaging handling, and owners routinely hitting 200k+ miles with nothing but oil changes. The rotary dial infotainment that reviewers love actually works once you learn it. But the new model ditches those physical controls just as competitors are bringing them back, and the community is furious. Shopping used or hunting a leftover 2025? You're golden. Eyeing the 2026? You're the guinea pig for Mazda's cost-cutting experiment, and early sentiment suggests they read the room wrong. Buy the outgoing model while you still can.
VW built a crossover with a genuinely clever AWD system and a cabin that feels more expensive than it is, then saddled it with an engine that gets outrun by a Corolla and a repair history that reads like a warranty company's nightmare. The 2025 redesign adds 17 horsepower and fixes some proportion issues, but still skips the hybrid powertrain every competitor offers. The real trouble is the 2018-2024 generation most buyers will encounter used: valve guide failures requiring cylinder head replacements, a water pump class action lawsuit, and the kind of repair frequency that turns $250/hour labor rates into a recurring expense. Lease it new and hand it back before 60k miles, or buy the RAV4 and sleep better. Long-term ownership means budgeting for European repair costs on a vehicle priced like a mainstream crossover.