← Back to Verdikt 
▼ ▼
Top Freezer Refrigerator
Maytag Top Freezer Refrigerator
⚠ Caution
Mixed signals, know the tradeoffs
A top-freezer with thoughtful design, a soft-freeze bin that keeps ice cream scoopable, three produce drawers instead of one chaotic crisper, fingerprint-resistant steel that actually works, but the through-door ice and water system fails catastrophically on multiple units straight from the factory. One owner logged five service calls in the first month with no fix; another's dispenser died on day one. The refrigeration itself seems sound, so if you're willing to forgo the convenience features entirely and use ice trays, you sidestep the trouble. But paying full price to gamble on whether your unit functions is a raw deal. Buy only if you plan to ignore the dispenser from the start or have the stamina to demand a replacement.
The context that matters
What you're actually buying — and what the data leans toward.
All reviews are incentivized Walmart promotional reviews collected during a promotion. No independent community or expert validation. Positive sentiment likely inflated by selection bias and promotional context.
−
Common complaints4 issues−Ice maker failures reported from day one requiring multiple service calls
−Water dispenser malfunctions reported on new units
−Ice cubes stick in dispenser and melt creating puddles
−Slightly louder operation than comparable models
✓
What owners praise6 strengths✓
Spacious interior with good shelf configuration
✓
Fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish
✓
Ice cream soft-freeze compartment keeps ice cream scoopable
✓
Three separate produce drawers for organization
✓
Side-by-side ice and water dispenser accessible without opening door
✓
Stainless steel shelf for rapid cooling
📊 How this score was calculated — 6-dimension rubric
Low confidence▼
Only 8 sources found — score may shift significantly with more data
69 sources analysed — thin data quality
Reliability & Durability(22%)5.0
No long-term owner data available — score is provisional
User Sentiment(22%)6.7
Post-count sentiment: 4 positive, 2 negative
Complaint Severity(16%)6.4
Complaints: 0 cosmetic, 4 functional, 2 systematic, 0 safety
Consensus Strength(8%)5.0
4 strongly positive, 2 strongly negative, 2 mixed/neutral
Value for Money(15%)5.5
No value signals detected
Owner Advocacy(17%)3.8
0 repurchased/gifted, 1 unprompted recommendations, 2 regrets
Scores are percentile ranks: 5.0 is the median product in existence. 8.5+ is reserved for genuinely exceptional products (top ~10%). The score reflects consensus quality, what owners say about the product. Risk is tracked separately and shown above the summary when present. Both are calculated deterministically, so the same signals always produce the same score.
🏆
How it ranks in Top Freezer Refrigerator
10 products compared
1
Amana Top Freezer Refrigerator
9.5/10
✓ Buy
2
Bosch 800 Series French Door Refrigerator
7.3/10
→ Consider
3
Bosch Counter-Depth Refrigerator (800 Series)
7.3/10
→ Consider
4
Whirlpool Top Freezer Refrigerator
7.1/10
→ Consider
5
Frigidaire Top Freezer Refrigerator
6.6/10
→ Consider
6
GE Cafe Counter Depth Refrigerator
6.4/10
⚠ Caution
7
LG Top Freezer Refrigerator
6.4/10
⚠ Caution
8
Frigidaire Side-by-Side Refrigerator
6.0/10
⚠ Caution
9
Maytag Top Freezer Refrigerator you are here
6.0/10
⚠ Caution
10
Frigidaire Bottom Freezer Refrigerator
5.9/10
⚠ Caution
If you're buying
Compare prices before you buy.From $299
Compare head-to-head
Maytag Top Freezer Refrigerator vs Frigidaire Side-by-Side RefrigeratorMaytag Top Freezer Refrigerator vs Frigidaire Bottom Freezer RefrigeratorMaytag Top Freezer Refrigerator vs Whirlpool Side-by-Side RefrigeratorMaytag Top Freezer Refrigerator vs Bosch Bottom Freezer RefrigeratorMaytag Top Freezer Refrigerator vs GE Cafe Counter Depth Refrigerator