← Back to Verdikt 
▼ ▼
Midsize Three-Row SUV
Honda Pilot
→ Consider
Solid choice with some caveats
Here's what you're actually buying: a spacious, dependable family hauler with a third row that fits humans, a removable middle seat that's genuinely clever, and a proven V6 that'll run to 200,000 miles without drama. The tradeoff is fuel economy, no hybrid option means high-teens MPG while Toyota sells Highlander Hybrids as fast as they can build them, and at $4/gallon that's real money over ownership. Interior materials on lower trims feel a step behind the CX-90 and Grand Highlander, and the styling won't turn heads. Buy it if you need maximum space and proven reliability and don't mind feeding the tank. Skip it if fuel economy or luxury feel matter more, the Grand Highlander Hybrid and CX-90 both answer those needs better.
The generation that matters
This product isn't one story — here's how each era is regarded.
1st generation (2003–2008)
2003–2008
Strong
Early models praised for Honda's signature reliability and practicality, though 2004 models at 200k miles are now considered high-risk due to age-related component degradation.
3rd generation (2016–2022)
2016–2022
Mixed
2016–2019 models flagged as 'some of the worst years to own' with common transmission, engine, and electrical issues; 2020–2022 models improved but still lack the standout qualities of newer or older generations.
4th generation (2023–present)
2023–present
Solid
Redesign praised for shedding 'minivan look,' improved AWD system, more space, and rugged TrailSport trim. Criticized for lack of hybrid option, forgettable styling, and high pricing, but regarded as well-rounded and practical.
−
Common complaints6 issues−No hybrid option available, fuel economy in high teens/low 20s MPG lags segment
−Interior materials on lower trims feel less upscale than Mazda CX-90 or Grand Highlander
−Small 9-inch screen with low resolution, especially poor in low light
−2016-2019 model years (previous generation) had transmission and electrical issues
−Pricing creeps toward MDX territory on top trims, value proposition weakens at Elite level
−Anonymous exterior styling, forgettable design compared to competitors
✓
What owners praise7 strengths✓
Class-leading interior space and cargo capacity, genuinely usable third row for adults
✓
Removable middle seat in second row (8-passenger configuration), unique flexibility in segment
✓
Proven V6 powertrain with 10-speed transmission, smooth, reliable, no CVT
✓
Strong long-term reliability reputation, owners reporting 200k+ miles with minimal issues
✓
TrailSport trim offers genuine off-road capability with full-size spare and improved AWD
✓
Practical, well-thought-out interior design, straightforward controls, good visibility
✓
Strong resale value and depreciation resistance compared to competitors
📊 How this score was calculated — 6-dimension rubric
High confidence▼
699 sources analysed with long-term owner data present
699 sources analysed — strong data quality
Reliability & Durability(22%)8.0
12 positive vs 3 negative long-term reports
User Sentiment(22%)8.1
3,847 positive upvotes vs 892 negative upvotes
Complaint Severity(16%)7.7
Complaints: 8 cosmetic, 14 functional, 2 systematic, 0 safety
Consensus Strength(8%)5.5
28 strongly positive, 4 strongly negative, 19 mixed/neutral
Value for Money(15%)5.1
15 'worth it', 7 'overpriced', 11 mention better-value alternatives
Owner Advocacy(17%)8.6
3 repurchased/gifted, 9 unprompted recommendations, 2 regrets
Scores are percentile ranks: 5.0 is the median product in existence. 8.5+ is reserved for genuinely exceptional products (top ~10%). The score reflects consensus quality, what owners say about the product. Risk is tracked separately and shown above the summary when present. Both are calculated deterministically, so the same signals always produce the same score.
Specifications2026
▼Pricing
Starting MSRP
$43,890
Range
$43,890 - $56,690
Capability
Fuel economy
20-22 MPG combined
Drivetrain
FWD standard / AWD optional
Dimensions & capacity
Seating
7-8 passengers
Powertrains
3.5L V-6
standard on all trims
285 hp
Trim pricing
TrailSport
7-seat with captain's chairs, off-road capable, wheelwell sound deadening
—
Elite
top trim, diamond-patterned faux-suede upholstery, acoustically laminated glass
$56,690
🏆
How it ranks in Midsize Three-Row SUV
7 products compared
1
Honda Pilot you are here
7.9/10
→ Consider
2
Subaru Ascent
7.2/10
→ Consider
3
Nissan Pathfinder
7.0/10
→ Consider
4
Volkswagen Atlas
6.5/10
→ Consider
5
Toyota Highlander
6.1/10
⚠ Caution
6
Buick Enclave
5.0/10
⚠ Caution
7
Kia Sorento
4.1/10
✕ Skip
If you're buying
Know what others paid before you walk in.